I inherited an online store that had never recorded a completed online purchase. Not a slow month. Never. Every report said "checkouts: 0", and the obvious conclusion, the one a sensible person draws in about four seconds, was that the website did not work.
The website worked fine. The dashboard was measuring a thing the business does not do.
Why would a store with no checkouts still be doing well?
Because of what it sells. This store sells cellphone contracts. Nobody buys a contract the way they buy a pair of socks. A customer picks a deal online, clicks Add to Quote, and the sale closes in the shop after a credit check, because the shop has to run a credit check before it can say yes.
So the real journey is: browse, add to quote, walk in, sign. The "checkout" step that every standard report waits for does not exist. A report built around checkouts was looking for a bus at an airport.
What does the "right" conversion look like for your business?
A conversion is just the action that matters most to you, counted. For a webshop it is often a purchase. For plenty of businesses it is something else:
- a quote request
- a phone call or WhatsApp tap
- a booked consultation
- a form that creates a lead
- a click on "directions" for a shop with a door
Ask one question: what is the last thing a person does on my website before they become money? That is your conversion, and it is the only number that can tell you whether the site is working.
How do I tell Google Analytics what to count?
In Google Analytics 4, the actions you care about are marked as key events. Until you mark one, GA4 will happily report a thousand visits and a calm, empty zero where your enquiries should be.
What I did for this store was simple to say and fiddly to do: I made Add to Quote the conversion that counts, on every platform, not only in analytics but in the other places that report on the store too.
If you only do one thing after reading this, ask the question above and write the answer on a sticky note. Then make sure every tool you use is counting that, and not something it was set up to count by default.
How do I check that my tracking is not fibbing?
Setting up a conversion is half the job. The other half is proving it fires, because a conversion that quietly does not count is worse than none: it gives you a confident wrong answer.
- Do it yourself. Click the button, submit the form, tap the phone number. Then watch it arrive. GA4 has a tool for this called DebugView that shows events as they happen.
- Compare against reality. If the sales team says six quote requests came in this week and your reports say two, one of them is wrong and it is rarely the sales team.
- Check each platform separately. Analytics, your ad accounts and your search tools each keep their own count. Google explains how its ad side works in About conversion measurement. The numbers will not match exactly, but they should tell the same story.
If you want to see how I think about this across a whole business, the case files walk through the real examples, including this one.
What else was quietly wrong?
Once the right number existed, I could see the rest of the mess clearly, which is rather the point of a right number.
- The store's Google, Meta and TikTok accounts were sitting under the previous agency's login.
- Four SEO apps were installed and were arguing with one another about what the pages should say.
- The product data that tells Google what each page is (called schema) was broken, and I traced it to the exact character where it failed.
- A theme update silently wiped the quote system. I rebuilt it and wrote a checklist so that cannot happen quietly again.
I cut the four SEO apps to one, wrote 12 articles across two new blogs, and replaced 17 banners and 4 homepage tiles with 94 images I made myself.
What happened once the right thing was being counted?
Before, the store did not show up in search and quote requests sat at zero. Now 4 to 5 come in every week. All of them organic, with no ad budget behind them yet. I mention the last bit because it is the question I get most often: "Why aren't the numbers bigger?" Because this is what it looks like when the foundations are fixed and nobody has yet paid to point a crowd at them.
I am not claiming the tracking change created those requests. What it did was let anyone see, for the first time, that the requests existed and were worth counting.
Frequently asked questions
What if my business closes sales by phone, not online?
Count the phone tap or the form submission as the conversion. Call tracking and WhatsApp click events can be added as key events too. It will not capture everything, but a consistent proxy beats a precise zero.
How many conversions should I track?
Start with one main one. More than three or four and the reports turn into soup. You can add small steps later, such as "viewed pricing", but keep one number as the boss.
Is a zero in my analytics always a tracking problem?
No. Sometimes it is a real zero. The giveaway is when other numbers (visits, searches, enquiries by email) are healthy while the conversion count never moves. That mismatch is the thing to investigate.
Can I do this myself?
Often, yes, if the action is a simple button or form. If your sales close offline, or across several tools, it is worth a 30-minute conversation before you start counting the wrong thing for another year.
