Google Search Console had been quietly collecting evidence. By the time I opened the report, 189 addresses on an online store were going nowhere, and the pile had been growing since March.
My first assumption, as I think everybody's is, was "a few broken links, no big deal." It is a very comforting sentence. It is also what people say about the first drip from a ceiling.
What is a broken link, and why does Google care?
A broken link is an address that used to show a page and now shows an error, usually a "404 page not found". Visitors who land on one leave. Google also notices. A handful of broken links is normal housekeeping. Hundreds, building up for months, make the place look neglected to every visitor who lands on one. Google explains how it treats these responses in its guide to HTTP status codes.
The damage is not only the dead page. Every old bookmark, every link from another site and every old search result that pointed to that address now leads to a wall.
Where do 189 broken links come from?
On this store, two habits produced all of them.
A bulk rename. Someone tidied the collection links. Tidy is good. But every old address stopped working, so every old bookmark and every search result still pointing there broke at once.
Expired deals. The store runs monthly deals. When a deal ended, it was deleted, and each deletion left a dead page behind. One deal is nothing. Twelve months of deals is a graveyard.
If you can name the habit that creates dead pages in your business (renaming, deleting, replacing a product line), you are most of the way to fixing the cause rather than the symptom.
How do you fix them without doing 189 jobs by hand?
You do not fix 189 things. You fix the patterns, because the 189 collapse into far fewer decisions.
The tool for this is a 301 redirect, a permanent signpost that says "this page has moved, go here instead." Google passes the old address's standing on to the new one.
The rules I followed:
- Group the dead addresses. Many share a pattern, so one rule can cover several.
- Send each to the closest relevant page. A discontinued deal goes to the nearest matching collection, not to the homepage. Sending everything to the homepage is the lazy fix, and Google can treat it as a "soft 404" anyway.
- Never force a match. If there is no sensible destination, let it stay a 404 rather than redirecting to something unrelated.
- Check the result. The 189 addresses were covered by 121 redirects, with zero errors.
The job is smaller than it looks once you stop treating each address as its own crisis.
What mistakes make redirects worse?
Redirects are simple, which is exactly why people get creative with them. Three habits to avoid:
- Chains. Old address goes to a middle address, which goes to the final one. Visitors and crawlers pay for every extra hop. Point each old address straight at the final destination.
- Loops. Address A sends you to B and B sends you back to A. The browser gives up and so does the visitor. (If this sounds familiar, the indexing story is the same kind of circle.)
- Forgetting to update your own links. If your menu or sitemap still points at the old address, you are making visitors take a detour inside your own house. Update the internal links as well as adding the redirect.
If you are planning a bigger change, such as a rename of everything or a move to a new address, Google has a thorough guide to site moves and migrations. Read it before you start, not after.
How do you stop it happening again?
This is the part I care about more, because an afternoon of redirects only buys you until the next tidy-up.
I built a small watcher. Once a week it compares the store against a saved snapshot. If a collection or deal has been renamed or removed, it redirects it to the closest match on its own.
On 14 September 2026 it earned its keep. Five deals had been removed. The watcher spotted all five and redirected them, and nobody touched anything. Finding out about a fix after it has already happened is the best way to find out about a fix.
Fixing the backlog is a good deed. Fixing the habit is the actual job.
What should I do on my own site this week?
- Open Search Console's Page indexing report and look for "Not found (404)".
- Work out which habit created them (rename, delete, replace).
- Redirect the ones that have a sensible home. Leave the genuinely gone ones alone.
- Put a reminder on the habit: "if we rename or remove it, we redirect it."
If you do the last one and nothing else, you are well ahead. And if your store or site is full of this kind of quiet leak, that is exactly what the case files are about, and I am happy to talk it through.
Frequently asked questions
Do broken links hurt my rankings?
A few do not. Large numbers of dead pages that other sites or old results still point to waste the value of those links and give visitors a bad first impression.
Should I redirect everything to the homepage?
No. Send each old address to the closest relevant page. Mass redirects to the homepage are usually treated like an error anyway.
301 or 302?
Use a 301 for a permanent move. A 302 says "temporary", and Google may keep the old address in its results.
Can this be automated?
For a store that changes often, yes. A weekly snapshot-and-compare script handles the routine cases, and a person only looks at the odd ones.
